Frequently Asked Questions

Can I join HLA's lawsuit against Optum Rx for PBM audit termination?

Unfortunately, PBM provider manuals contain provisions that prohibit "class actions," meaning the joining of multiple plaintiffs against a defendant in one complaint.

Am I able to file a lawsuit against Optum Rx for PBM audit violations?

Yes, you are entitled to file a lawsuit in federal or state court to hold the PBM accountable for PBM audit violations. Ultimately, however, lawsuits should be a remedy of last resort if PBM audit negotiations fail.

What are the costs associated with filing a PBM audit lawsuit?

Legal fees and expenses vary depending on the nature of the lawsuit and claims involved. Some PBM audit lawsuits may be resolved quickly, whereas others may take longer or be referred to arbitration. Finally, certain claims may be eligible for "contingent fee" arrangements, particularly if you are a specialty pharmacy with high DIR claw-backs.

Among the major PBMs, Optum is perhaps the most aggressive when it comes to PBM audit sanctions, and we have scores of clients facing network termination for relatively inconsequential audit violations. In this case, however, Optum reversed the scheduled termination of our client based on HLA's advocacy and commitment to holding PBMs accountable to their legal obligations. A brief summary is provided below, but the road to this victory was long and hard.

2023 PBM Audit of Texas Pharmacy

Based on a July 2023 audit that noted significant claim discrepancies based on patient denials and inventory shortages, Optum served a notice of termination on the pharmacy based on "potential fraud, waste and/or abuse."

At that point, HLA was retained and our attorneys worked closely with the client to develop the narrative and formulate strategy for an appeal.

PBM Audit Appeal by Texas Pharmacy

Optum's initial termination letter was based on inventory shortages and the pharmacy's failure to provide a broad array of acute and maintenance medications to service routine retail pharmacy customers.

During the appeal process, HLA worked with the client to prepare and submit substantial documentation of compliance to all applicable Provider Manual rules and legal obligations.

During the appeal, however, Optum updated the original basis of termination to add new grounds. Not long afterwards, Optum's Pharmacy Programs Department denied the pharmacy's appeal and upheld network termination.

HLA Puts Optum on Notice of Potential Litigation

As we have written, litigation is an option of last resort, and should be commenced only when all other resolutions have failed. Here, however, the pharmacy's business was about to be bankrupted by network termination, and it had run out of options.

Accordingly, HLA notified Optum that, unless it agreed to reconsider its termination decision, HLA would have no choice but to file a lawsuit in federal court. Optum subsequently agreed to reconvene a panel, consisting of Optum attorneys and pharmacy professionals, to hear HLA's arguments why our client should not be terminated.

Optum Panel Reverses Termination of Texas Pharmacy

During HLA's meticulous and detailed presentation to Optum's panel, HLA attorney Diana Yastrovskaya, a member of the firm's national PBM audit defense team, used the time to educate Optum as to the challenges independent pharmacies are facing, and explain how Optum's approach to PBM audit sanctions could be better-tailored to arrive at mutually beneficial solutions.

In addition, Ms. Yastrovskaya noted that Texas PBM audit reform laws have changed the way in which PBMs are required to conduct PBM audits, such that Optum's audit conduct and network termination were unlawful.

Days later, Optum reversed its termination of the pharmacy. Let's be clear, however: Optum did not reverse its termination voluntarily or willingly. It did so because HLA attorneys were willing to go to court, as we have done before, to hold Optum accountable to its legal obligations.

If you are in a similar situation, put HLA's attorneys on your side today. Call now for a free consultation.

MORE ARTICLES BY CATEGORY

Get a Free Case REVIEW

100% Confidential & Secure. Your details are safe with us.

We'll speak soon!

In the meantime, why not find out more about us or visit our blog.

Alternatively, give us a call at (800) 345 - 4125

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Resolving Prescription “Red Flags” Is No Longer Optional: Federal Scrutiny Tightens on Controlled-Substance Dispensing

Pharmacists must resolve “red flags” under the Controlled Substances Act’s corresponding-responsibility requirements before dispensing controlled substances. Overlooking warning signs, such as cash-paid, high-dose opioid prescriptions—can now trigger False Claims Act liability and massive penalties, as demonstrated by Walgreens’ $350 million settlement in April 2025.

Read More >>

9th Circuit’s Landmark EKRA Ruling—What Providers Should Know

On July 11, 2025, the 9th Circuit upheld a laboratory operator’s convictions for violating EKRA by paying marketing agents to mislead providers into providing patient referrals for medically unnecessary blood tests. In this article, we analyze the 9th Circuit’s ruling and what it means for the future of EKRA enforcement.

Read More >>

Collateral Consequences Mount Quickly After Adverse DEA Inspection

Adverse findings during a DEA inspection can trigger a chain reaction of serious consequences for pharmacies, including increasing fines, suspension or revocation of DEA registrations and pharmacy licenses, costly False Claims Act (FCA) lawsuits, and potential criminal liability.

Read More >>

Heath Law Alliance Secures Reversal of a Medicaid Payment Suspension

Health Law Alliance successfully secured a full reversal of a Medi-Cal payment suspension for a California pharmacy, overturning speculative allegations made by the Department of Health Care Services. This case highlights the firm’s ability to protect healthcare providers against unjust enforcement actions and the critical value of experienced legal counsel in Medicaid and insurance disputes.

Read More >>