RPM and CCM Audit Defense · MAC · UPIC · RAC · OIG · Private Payors

Remote Patient Monitoring & CCM Audit Attorneys

One remote patient monitoring (RPM) or chronic care management (CCM) audit can put your revenue, practice and license at risk. A routine request for device data and time logs can turn into an overpayment demand, prepayment review, a payment suspension or a False Claims Act investigation. Get advice from experienced audit attorneys before you turn over a single record.

We Stop Enforcement Overreach at Every Stage
  • Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) additional documentation requests
  • Targeted Probe and Educate (TPE) reviews
  • Unified Program Integrity Contractor (UPIC) and Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) audits
  • HHS Office of Inspector General (HHS-OIG) audits and investigations
  • Medicare Advantage and private payor audits
  • Prepayment review and payment suspensions
  • Overpayment demands and Medicare appeals
Request an RPM and CCM Audit Defense Review
RPM and CCM Audit Defense Hotline · Direct Line
(800) 345 - 4125
Overview

Did a Medicare Contractor, OIG or a Payor Question Your RPM or CCM Claims?

Telehealth is transforming healthcare, and remote patient monitoring (RPM) is leading the way. But in 2025, the Office of Inspector General (OIG) is zeroing in on RPM services, meaning that providers using RPM face audits and investigations from federal regulators, Medicare Administrative Contractors (MACs), and even private payors. Even small errors in documentation or coding can quickly snowball. The result? Major financial consequences for your practice.

Chronic care management (CCM) claims draw the same scrutiny. Medicare pays for both services in monthly cycles: RPM for days of device data and minutes of treatment management, and CCM for minutes of care. None of these audits are done at random, and an audit or document request should serve as a warning that your Medicare claims have come under a microscope.

At Health Law Alliance, we partner with RPM and CCM providers to navigate complicated regulations and payor requirements. We help you get paid fairly and avoid big risks, giving you peace of mind to use and bill for RPM services with confidence.

We defend physician practices, providers whose patients live in nursing homes, skilled nursing facilities and senior living facilities, and the monitoring and billing companies that support them, from the first records request through anything that follows, including UPIC investigations, Medicare appeals and False Claims Act referrals. Providers should never respond to an audit, even a simple document request, without a clear read on their risk and an understanding of what may follow. Our attorneys have overseen more than 2,000 audits, and our team is led by Anthony Mahajan, a former federal prosecutor and UnitedHealth Chief Compliance Officer. We handle the audit, allowing you to focus on patient care.

RPM and CCM Audit Checklist

HLA’s Guide for RPM and CCM Audits & Investigations

We created this guide to assist providers with RPM and CCM audits, but it cannot substitute for advice tailored to your unique circumstances.

01

Identify the contractor and the kind of review

Not all audits are created equal, and knowing the type of review and who is asking determines how you respond. A Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) such as Palmetto GBA, Noridian, Novitas, National Government Services, First Coast, WPS or CGS issues additional documentation requests, runs Targeted Probe and Educate reviews and places high error rate providers on prepayment claim review. A Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) such as Performant or Cotiviti reviews paid claims for overpayment on a contingency basis. A Unified Program Integrity Contractor (UPIC) such as Qlarant, SafeGuard Services or CoventBridge investigates suspected fraud, waste and abuse, and it can conduct site visits and interviews, recommend payment suspension and refer the matter to HHS-OIG or the local U.S. Attorney’s office. HHS-OIG also audits RPM and CCM billing directly.

Medicare Advantage plans and private payors run their own special investigation units, and their audits follow the payor contract as well as Medicare rules. Match the response to the auditor and the review type before anything else.

02

Treat the first records request as the start of the case, and calendar its deadline

Most audits start quietly, with a request for a small number of charts. It rarely stays that way. Once the initial sample is reviewed, contractors widen the date range, add claim types and expand into other services. The language used, the documents provided and the explanations offered in that first response become the foundation for the auditor’s conclusions, and early mistakes are hard to undo later.

Response windows differ by contractor and by review type, and the controlling deadline is the one printed in the request, not a remembered standard. Date-stamp the letter, confirm when it was received and work backward so that legal and clinical review happen before the production date rather than on it. Where records are not produced on time, the contractor is able to deny the sampled claims outright for lack of supporting documentation.

03

Check every RPM claim against the elements of each code billed

RPM is billed in parts: education and device setup, the device supply with daily recording or transmission, and treatment management. A reviewer tests each part on its own, and a month can fail on one part while the others hold. For each patient and month under review, assemble the evidence for every code billed.

What an RPM claim file should show
  • The patient’s consent to monitoring, written or verbal, documented in the record
  • An established relationship with the patient and a documented reason for monitoring
  • A device that meets the FDA definition of a medical device and transmits readings automatically, rather than readings the patient types in or reports by phone
  • The days of data the code requires: code 99454 requires at least 16 days of readings in a 30-day period, and since January 1, 2026, code 99445 covers 2 to 15 days
  • Treatment management time: at least 20 minutes for 99457 and each additional 20 minutes for 99458, including the interactive communication with the patient those codes require; since January 1, 2026, code 99470 covers 10 to 19 minutes
  • Time records showing who did the work, on what date and for how long, recorded when it was done
  • At least 30 minutes of the physician’s or qualified health care professional’s own time collecting and interpreting the data where 99091 is billed
04

Check every CCM claim against the care plan and the clock

Medicare pays for CCM by the calendar month, and each code carries a time threshold. A month without the minutes, the consent or the care plan behind it is a month the reviewer can deny.

What a CCM claim file should show
  • Two or more chronic conditions expected to last at least 12 months, or until death, that place the patient at significant risk
  • Documented consent, written or verbal, including that only one practitioner can bill CCM in a calendar month and that cost sharing applies
  • An initiating visit for new patients and for patients not seen within the past year
  • A comprehensive care plan, kept electronically and shared with the patient
  • Round-the-clock access to the care team and continuity of care with a designated team member
  • Time records that meet the code billed: 20 minutes of clinical staff time for 99490, 30 minutes of the practitioner’s own time for 99491, 60 minutes of clinical staff time for complex CCM under 99487, and add-on codes 99439, 99437 and 99489 only for additional time actually spent
05

Count every minute once

Time counted toward CCM cannot also be counted toward another service, and Medicare allows RPM or remote therapeutic monitoring (RTM), not both, to be billed alongside CCM. OIG’s 2019 audit of CCM billing, applying the rules then in force, found $640,452 in overpayments on 20,165 claims from 2015 and 2016: 14,078 were duplicate claims and 6,087 billed CCM alongside overlapping care management services.

Before anything is produced, line up every code billed for each patient in each month and confirm that no minute and no service is counted twice, including by a second practice billing for the same patient.

06

Check the rule that applied on the date of service

RPM and CCM billing rules change with the annual Medicare Physician Fee Schedule. A rule in force today may not have governed the date of service under review. On January 1, 2026, Medicare began paying for shorter monitoring periods under new codes.

Pulling the correct historical policy is a small amount of work at the outset that can dispose of entire categories of denials later.

07

Understand what can and cannot be fixed

A well-intentioned effort to fix a chart creates a second problem on top of the first, and the second one can be worse. Authentication is different from supplementation, and supplementation is different from rewriting history. A note added late, a time log rebuilt after the request arrived or a consent form signed after the fact will raise suspicions.

Before changing or adding anything after the audit has started, determine what the applicable CMS rule actually permits and preserve the original entry. There may be room to address some omissions properly, but strict rules apply.

08

Produce exactly what is required, organized so the reviewer can follow it

One common mistake is treating the response as an export: pulling every device report, uploading thousands of pages and assuming the reviewer will find the evidence that matters. The opposite mistake is sending less than what was asked. A defensible claim can be denied when the evidence is buried or never tied to the requirement being tested, and once a record is produced it can be used for any purpose, including new audits and recoupment demands.

A defensible production typically includes
  • A transmittal letter identifying the request, production date, beneficiaries and enclosed materials
  • A beneficiary-by-beneficiary index, organized by month of service
  • Consistent pagination or Bates numbering
  • Device data and time records matched to each month billed
  • Clear separation between contemporaneous records and later-created explanatory materials
  • A coverage map showing where each required element appears in the record
09

Assume extrapolation, and prepare to challenge it

A review of 30 to 50 claims can become a six- or seven-figure demand when the contractor projects the sample error rate across every claim in the audit window. Because RPM and CCM are billed every month for every enrolled patient, the audit window can hold thousands of claims.

Under 42 U.S.C. § 1395ddd(f)(3), extrapolation requires a determination of a sustained or high level of payment error or a documented failure of a prior educational intervention. CMS sets out how contractors must sample and extrapolate in the Medicare Program Integrity Manual. Challenges to extrapolation methodology commonly focus on whether the sampling units were properly defined and independent, whether the random selection was documented and replicable, and whether the statistical assumptions behind the point estimate hold.

Questions worth asking as soon as the request arrives
  • How many claims were requested, and over what span of dates of service?
  • Has the contractor identified a basis for a sustained or high level of payment error, or a prior failed educational intervention?
  • Was there a prior Targeted Probe and Educate episode or probe review?
  • What is the sampling frame, the universe definition, the random-number documentation and the full methodology?
10

Control communications and look closely at vendor arrangements

Designate one point of contact, preferably counsel or a trained compliance leader, and route every communication through that person. Keep a contemporaneous log of every contact: date, participants, topic, documents requested, what was said and any follow-up promised.

Many practices furnish RPM and CCM through an outside company that supplies devices, staff or software, and some are paid per enrolled patient. How patients were enrolled, who did the work and how the company is paid can matter as much as the chart.

Signs the matter may be more than an audit
  • The letter cites potential fraud, a credible allegation or a referral
  • It comes from a UPIC rather than a MAC, or names HHS-OIG
  • Patients are asked whether they agreed to monitoring or used the device
  • Questions turn to the monitoring company, its staff or how patients were enrolled
  • Questions turn to payments between the practice and a vendor, marketer or referral source
  • Payment suspension or prepayment review is imposed

If you need assistance working through any of these questions, the attorneys at Health Law Alliance have the experience and background necessary to guide the response. We offer flexible fee arrangements and competitive rates.

Do Not Respond without a Plan

Our experienced attorneys have assisted thousands of providers in navigating the same challenges you are facing.

Speak With an RPM and CCM Audit Attorney →
What Auditors Look For

Common issues identified during RPM and CCM audits

RPM and CCM findings cluster around consent, devices, days of data, minutes and overlap. Auditors judge the record months or years after the service, without the clinical context the provider had, and each item below is a place where that hindsight is applied.

Exposure

Potential Consequences of an RPM or CCM Audit

An RPM or CCM audit can quickly escalate far beyond a routine records request, including

Former professional experience

Where Our Attorneys Served Before Health Law Alliance

Department of Justice

Agency and company marks identify former professional experience of individual HLA team members. They do not imply affiliation, endorsement, or a client relationship.

Health Law Alliance attorneys
The HLA Team

RPM and CCM Audit Defense Attorneys

RPM and CCM audit matters can cross prepayment review, payment suspension, the five-level Medicare appeal, payor contract disputes, False Claims Act exposure and criminal referrals. Health Law Alliance handles the audit response and any parallel appeal or referral as one coordinated matter.

Common RPM and CCM Audit Triggers

The six patterns that put an RPM or CCM audit in motion

CMS, HHS-OIG and payors select practices for RPM and CCM review from claims data, published OIG metrics and referrals. The following triggers are the most common predicates for a records request, prepayment review notice or focused review.

01
Data analytics and OIG’s RPM metrics
OIG’s August 2025 data snapshot found that Medicare paid more than $500 million for RPM in 2024, for nearly 1 million enrollees, and set out metrics for spotting billing that warrants review: sudden jumps in new enrollees, patients with no prior visit at the practice, patients billed for monitoring who never received treatment management, enrollees shared with other practices and multiple devices per patient. Practices at the top of those distributions are more likely to be flagged for review.
02
CCM time below the code threshold
CCM enforcement follows the minutes. In February 2025, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of New York announced that a medical practice agreed to pay $251,477 to resolve allegations that it billed CCM without providing at least 20 minutes of clinical staff time.
03
Monitoring company and vendor arrangements
In June 2025, a remote patient monitoring company and its owner agreed to pay $1.29 million to resolve allegations, raised in a whistleblower suit by former employees, that they caused Medicare claims for RPM using devices that did not automatically report readings. When an outside company supplies the devices, the staff or the enrolled patients, its conduct can become the billing practice’s exposure.
04
Medicare Advantage and private payor reviews
Medicare Advantage plans and private payors run their own analytics on RPM and CCM claims, and billing that stands out from the plan’s peer group can prompt a special investigation unit records request and recoupment under the payor contract.
05
State Medicaid Fraud Control Unit (MFCU) cross-referral
State fraud control units investigate Medicaid claims and refer matters to CMS for parallel Medicare review when the provider participates in both programs, and the referral runs in the other direction too. The state-federal coordination is increasingly tight, and a defense that handles only one side often misses or compromises the exposure on the other.
06
Whistleblower or qui tam complaint referral
A qui tam complaint filed under seal, often by a former employee or biller, can produce a contractor review when the DOJ Civil Division wants a billing analysis to support the case. The records request that follows rarely identifies the underlying complaint, but its scope tracks the allegations closely enough that experienced defense counsel can recognize the matter behind it.
RPM and CCM Audit Defense FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Nine questions that come up on almost every first call. The answers below are general; specific situations require privileged consultation.

Remote patient monitoring, or RPM, is a form of asynchronous telehealth delivery where providers use digital medical devices to collect a patient’s health data. RPM can be incredibly beneficial in assisting with care coordination, making it an easy way to collect real-time information to effectively monitor and manage a patient’s condition. RPM can also be a lucrative service for providers wanting to generate additional revenue for their practice. But ensuring your RPM billing practices are compliant is not without challenges. At Health Law Alliance, we can help you create billing policies and procedures and minimize your audit risk, allowing you to provide and bill for RPM services with confidence.
Chronic care management is non-face-to-face care coordination for patients with two or more chronic conditions, billed by the calendar month. It is built on a comprehensive care plan, documented patient consent and time spent by clinical staff or the billing practitioner, measured against the threshold for each code. Because CCM and RPM are often furnished to the same patients by the same practice, auditors frequently review them together.
Yes. While RPM is used in a number of specialties, internal medicine, family medicine, and cardiology practices may be more susceptible to audits, as these specialties bill for RPM more frequently. But any practice can be selected for an audit, particularly if practice data shows a pattern of excessive or unusual billing patterns for RPM services. No matter your practice area, having a team with decades of audit defense and compliance experience is essential to protect your business.
Like other telehealth services, usage of RPM services has exploded since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, drawing regulators’ attention as a potential hotbed for fraud. In 2024, OIG published a report indicating the need for increased oversight of RPM services in Medicare, indicating that approximately 43% of patients did not receive all of the components required for billing. This report led OIG to add auditing Part B RPM services to its 2025 Work Plan. Private payors have also taken notice, increasingly focusing on RPM claims in fraud, waste and abuse (FWA) audits.
The Medicare appeal track has five levels with strict deadlines. Level 1 is the redetermination request to the MAC, due within 120 days of the initial determination. Level 2 is the reconsideration request to a Qualified Independent Contractor (QIC), due within 180 days of the redetermination. Level 3 is the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) hearing, due within 60 days of the QIC reconsideration; the ALJ level has historically carried a substantial backlog. Level 4 is the Medicare Appeals Council review. Level 5 is federal district court review under 42 U.S.C. § 405(g). A missed deadline can forfeit the appeal at that level unless good cause for the delay is shown. The redetermination and reconsideration are the most consequential steps because the record built there is the record the ALJ will review. Medicare Advantage and private payor audits follow the appeal terms of the payor contract instead.
When the findings suggest intent rather than error: monitoring billed for patients who never used a device, time billed that was never spent, patients enrolled without their consent, or payments to a vendor or marketer for enrolled patients. The civil referral runs through the DOJ Civil Division and may surface as a Civil Investigative Demand. The criminal referral runs through the local U.S. Attorney or the DOJ Fraud Section and may surface as a grand jury subpoena or a target letter.
We offer flexible fee arrangements based on the scope of audit representation required and the stage of the audit. The earlier we are involved the better, as we can shape and limit the audit scope, making legal representation more effective and less costly.
Immediately upon receiving any audit notice, and before responding to the first records request. Early intervention preserves appeal rights, controls how the matter is framed and protects your reimbursement and your license. The first production shapes everything that follows: which patients and months the contractor reviews, what claim universe the sample is drawn from and whether the contractor sees patterns that escalate to referral. A production made without counsel can become evidence in later civil and criminal proceedings.
Our experienced healthcare audit attorneys are ready to help you every step of the way. From preparing a tailored audit response strategy to handling all communications with auditors and regulators, we help you prevent common mistakes that could place your practice under increased scrutiny. But we don’t stop there: we rigorously advocate for you even after audits end, challenging unwarranted findings and overseeing the appeal process from start to finish. We proactively investigate issues and help you develop compliance strategies to reduce your risk of an OIG or DOJ referral.
  • Comprehensive Audit Preparation: We review your practices to find and fix compliance risks before audits happen.
  • Appeals and Legal Representation: Our team represents you throughout the audit process, from handling communications with regulators and auditors to navigating appeals.
  • Ongoing Compliance Guidance: Our attorneys create custom compliance plans for your practice. We tailor our advice to your unique risk areas to catch billing errors before they become vulnerabilities.
5,000+Matters handled
2,500+Clients represented
2,000+Audits overseen
ImmediateAttorney response
Health Law Alliance

Book a Free Consultation

Speak with an experienced attorney today at no cost - evaluate your situation and learn how we can help. Confidential, no obligation.

(800) 345 - 4125
Get RPM & CCM Audit Advice from Attorney-Clinicians