A physical therapy claim can fail in three places: the minutes documented, the clinician who actually touched the patient, and whether a service billed as attended was left running on its own. The civil False Claims Act reaches a knowingly false claim on any one of them, and the government does not have to prove the practice intended to defraud Medicare. In March 2026, Team Rehabilitation Services, LLC, which operates physical therapy clinics across Michigan, Illinois, Indiana, Wisconsin, and Georgia, agreed to pay $4,969,494 to resolve allegations that it violated the False Claims Act by submitting false claims for payment for physical therapy services to several federal healthcare programs, according to the HHS-OIG. The sections below cover each of those three failure points in turn.
Time-Based Coding and the One-to-One Requirement
Medicare pays many therapy codes, including 97110 (therapeutic exercise) and 97112 (neuromuscular reeducation), as timed codes billed in 15-minute units. Under the Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 5, Section 20.2, a practice should not bill a timed service performed for less than 8 minutes, and the required minutes scale up from there for each additional unit. The rule assumes direct, one-on-one time between clinician and patient. The same unit count also feeds the separate financial threshold that triggers additional Medicare review, covered in Physical Therapy Medicare Audits and the Therapy Threshold.
Supervision of Aides and Physical Therapist Assistants
A physical therapist assistant (PTA) may furnish care under a supervising therapist, but the required supervision level depends on the setting. The Medicare Benefit Policy Manual, Chapter 15, Section 230.1, requires general supervision of a PTA in most settings and direct supervision in a private practice, meaning the supervising therapist must be in the office suite and immediately available. An aide is a different category: the same section states that services provided by aides, even under a therapist's supervision, are not therapy services and are not covered by Medicare. A claim that carries a licensed clinician's name for work an aide actually performed misrepresents who furnished the service, and a qui tam relator, often a current or former employee protected from retaliation under FCA Retaliation Claims Under Section 3730(h), is positioned to see it first.
Unattended Modalities and the Constant-Attendance Distinction
Not every modality requires a clinician's continuous presence. CPT codes 97032 through 97036 are constant-attendance codes: CMS's Medicare Coverage Database guidance states these codes require direct, one-on-one contact, and the provider cannot bill another procedure at the same time. HCPCS code G0283 (electrical stimulation, unattended), by contrast, is a supervised modality that does not require one-on-one contact, though it must still be set up and monitored under the plan of care. Billing a constant-attendance code for a modality that ran unattended, or billing a supervised modality as though it demanded the clinician's full attention, misstates the service delivered.
The False Claims Act Knowing Standard
31 U.S.C. Section 3729(b)(1) defines knowing to include actual knowledge, deliberate ignorance, or reckless disregard of whether a claim is true, and requires no proof of specific intent to defraud. A single mis-timed note, without more, does not show the actual knowledge or conscious disregard the statute requires. Practices that litigate rather than settle face the trial exposure described in Going to Trial in a False Claims Act Case, and a materiality argument, covered in The Materiality Defense After Escobar, is one of the defenses available once a case is filed.
A civil False Claims Act case does not require proof that a physical therapy practice intended to defraud Medicare. It requires only that the practice knew, or recklessly disregarded, that a billed claim was false.
Why early legal counsel is critical: physical therapy practices should promptly retain experienced healthcare defense counsel upon learning of a qui tam complaint, a civil investigative demand, or any other sign of a government inquiry into therapy billing. Early legal intervention protects the practice's rights, shapes how it responds to document requests, preserves defenses before litigation positions harden, and lets counsel communicate with investigators on the practice's behalf. Delaying representation narrows the defenses available later.
How Health Law Alliance can help: Health Law Alliance defends physical therapy practices and their owners through every stage of a False Claims Act matter, from the sealed investigation period through intervention, settlement, and any resulting corporate integrity agreement or OIG exclusion proceeding. If your practice is facing a qui tam complaint or a government inquiry into therapy billing, contact Health Law Alliance for a free, confidential consultation to review the claims at issue.
Health Law Alliance's attorneys have overseen 2,000+ audits and handled 5,000+ matters, with 25+ years of experience.





