A physician weighing a new referral relationship, medical directorship, or space-sharing arrangement can ask the HHS Office of Inspector General whether that specific arrangement violates the Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS) before signing it. The OIG advisory opinion process exists for exactly that question, though its reach is narrower than its name suggests: it covers the AKS and related civil monetary penalty authorities, binds only the requestor, and stops short of the Stark Law, fair market value, and any arrangement regulators are already examining.
What an OIG Advisory Opinion Covers
OIG issues advisory opinions on four questions under 42 CFR Part 1008: what counts as prohibited remuneration under the anti-kickback statute; whether a specific arrangement fits one of the statute's safe harbors; what counts as an improper inducement to reduce or limit patient care; and whether an activity could support exclusion or a civil monetary penalty under the Social Security Act's fraud and abuse provisions. An opinion binds only the Department of Health and Human Services and the individual or entity that requested it. No other provider may rely on an opinion OIG issued to someone else, and a party that was not the requestor cannot introduce that opinion as evidence in its own matter.
What an OIG Advisory Opinion Will Not Cover
OIG will not accept a request that fails to name the actual parties and the actual arrangement, and it will not take on a question that would require extensive investigation, clinical study, or testing to answer. Two exclusions recur in physician arrangements, both tied to subject matter OIG places outside its own authority. The first is the Stark Law: OIG's own guidance states that opinions about the physician self-referral law fall to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, not OIG, so an arrangement that raises both statutes needs separate review under each one. The second is fair market value. OIG will not tell a requestor whether a specific compensation figure is fair market value, even though fair market value is itself an element of several AKS safe harbors.
The Request, the Fee, and the Clock
A formal request goes to OIG in writing and describes the real parties and the real arrangement, not a hypothetical version of it. OIG sends an initial response, accepting, rejecting, or asking for more information, within 10 working days, and commits to issuing the opinion itself within 60 days of formally accepting the request. That clock pauses while OIG waits on additional information, outside consultant advice, or payment. Requestors pay OIG's actual cost of review rather than a flat fee; OIG has said the least complex requests run $5,000 to $8,000, and more complex ones $10,000 or more, due before the opinion issues.
An arrangement already named in a civil investigative demand or a grand jury subpoena is not a candidate for an advisory opinion. It is a candidate for defense counsel.
Deciding Whether to Ask
The process fits a narrow moment: before the arrangement is final, while the parties can still restructure terms OIG flags as risky. It fits poorly once regulators are already looking at the arrangement. A physician or practice that has received a civil investigative demand or a grand jury subpoena naming the same arrangement is past the point OIG's own rule against taking on facts needing extensive investigation would allow, and needs a defense posture rather than a request for guidance. An issued opinion also becomes a public document, redacted for identifying detail, so a provider weighing one should expect regulators and competitors to read OIG's reasoning, even though only the requestor can rely on it.
Why Early Legal Counsel Is Critical
It is critical that physicians and practices retain experienced healthcare defense counsel before finalizing an arrangement that raises Anti-Kickback Statute or Stark Law questions, and immediately upon receiving a subpoena or civil investigative demand tied to an existing one. Early legal review can shape whether an advisory opinion request makes sense, identify which safe harbor terms the arrangement should meet, and preserve defenses that are harder to raise once regulators have formed a view. Waiting until a regulator raises the question can affect the outcome of the matter.
How Health Law Alliance Can Help
Health Law Alliance's attorneys have overseen 2,000+ audits and handled 5,000+ matters, with 25+ years of experience.
Health Law Alliance's healthcare fraud defense attorneys advise physicians and practices on Anti-Kickback Statute and Stark Law exposure before an arrangement is signed, and defend providers who are already facing a government inquiry into one. If your practice is weighing a new arrangement or has received a subpoena or civil investigative demand about an existing one, contact Health Law Alliance for a free, confidential consultation.





