On November 16, 2026, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services released the CRUSH proposed rule, CMS-6098-P. The proposal would change how a Medicaid or CHIP program acts on a credible allegation of fraud, when a provider must report and return an overpayment, and how much data a state checks before it pays a claim. Providers in personal care services, adult day care, and applied behavior analysis, the areas CMS names as high risk for Medicaid fraud, sit closest to nearly every piece of it. None of the proposed changes are in effect; the rule is scheduled for Federal Register publication on November 19, 2026, opening a 60-day public comment period.
Credible Allegations of Fraud and Payment Suspensions
Under current 42 CFR 455.23(a), a state Medicaid agency must suspend Medicaid payments to a provider once it determines there is a credible allegation of fraud under investigation, unless it has good cause under 455.23(e) not to suspend, or to suspend only in part. CMS proposes to revise the definition of credible allegation of fraud at 455.2 so a state may adopt a determination CMS or another federal agency already made as its own finding, without independently re-verifying it. CMS also proposes to narrow the good cause exception at 455.23(e), requiring a state to document in writing that the invoked exception's criteria are actually met. CMS's data found that roughly 75 percent of credible allegation of fraud cases it reviewed in CY 2025 ended in a good cause exception instead of a suspension, covered further in Medicaid Payment Suspensions Under 42 CFR 455.23 and Good Cause Exceptions to a Medicaid Payment Suspension.
A Proposed 60-Day Overpayment Deadline
CMS proposes a new rule for the Medicaid fee-for-service program at new 455.904(b): a provider that identifies an overpayment would have to report and return it to the state by the later of 60 days after identification or the date a related cost report is due. That clock already exists in the underlying statute, section 1128J(d) of the Act, where retaining a known overpayment past the deadline is already enforceable under the False Claims Act. The proposed rule would make the deadline concrete for Medicaid fee-for-service specifically, the same clock a provider already working through a recoupment finding would face for anything it later identifies.
Electronic Visit Verification in Prepayment Review
CMS proposes to put states' existing electronic visit verification, or EVV, systems to a new use: amending 455.14 so a preliminary investigation into suspected fraud by a personal care or home health provider must include a review of EVV records, and amending 447.45(f)(1) so EVV records support any such claim a state reviews before paying it. A mismatch between a billed claim and its EVV record could now surface during prepayment review rather than after a provider has already filed an audit appeal.
New Enrollment, Disclosure and Reporting Requirements
CMS proposes new and revised denial and termination grounds for Medicaid and CHIP providers at 455.416, mirroring Medicare's own grounds: a felony conviction within the preceding 10 years for crimes against persons, a felony that put the program or beneficiaries at risk, or a felony resulting in a mandatory OIG exclusion. The proposal would also expand ownership and managing employee disclosures, require states to collect National Provider Identifiers for every eligible provider, and add a monthly report, at new 455.418, naming every provider a state denied, terminated, or was required to act against but did not. The current denial and screening framework is covered in Medicaid Enrollment Denials and Provider Screening.
What This Means for High-Risk-Area Providers
For providers in personal care services, adult day care, and applied behavior analysis, the high-risk Medicaid areas CMS names on its own fraud prevention page, a federal finding and a state suspension are no longer separate problems on separate tracks. Confirm the overpayment process can meet a 60-day clock, check that EVV records match what is billed, and review ownership and managing employee disclosures before monthly reporting of denials and terminations becomes routine. Adult day care providers face this gap directly, covered in Social Adult Day Care Prepayment Review and Payment Suspension.
Under the proposed rule, a federal fraud finding would not stay a federal problem: CMS proposes letting a state adopt it as the state's own finding and move straight to a Medicaid payment suspension.
Why Early Legal Counsel Is Critical
It is critical that Medicaid and CHIP providers, especially those in personal care services, adult day care, and applied behavior analysis, promptly retain experienced healthcare defense counsel upon receiving any notice of a credible allegation of fraud, a payment suspension, or a request tied to an identified overpayment. Early legal intervention can protect the provider's rights, test whether a federal finding and a state's reliance on it actually hold up, and preserve defenses that are harder to raise once investigators have formed a view of the facts.
How Health Law Alliance Can Help
Health Law Alliance's attorneys have overseen 2,000+ audits and handled 5,000+ matters, with 25+ years of experience.
Health Law Alliance's Medicaid audit defense attorneys represent providers in personal care services and other high-risk Medicaid areas through credible allegation of fraud findings, payment suspensions, and overpayment disputes. If your practice is facing a Medicaid payment suspension, an overpayment review, or a related federal matter, contact Health Law Alliance for a free, confidential consultation.





