Medicare's refill rule for durable medical equipment, prosthetics, orthotics, and supplies (DMEPOS) turns a routine shipment into a documented transaction. DMEPOS refill audits sit inside the broader Medicare audit landscape, and suppliers billing for recurring refills, such as continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) supplies and continuous glucose monitor (CGM) supplies, must contact the beneficiary before every refill and capture an affirmative response. A DME Medicare Administrative Contractor, or a Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) reviewing the same claims later, does not ask whether the beneficiary needed the item. It asks whether the supplier can produce the contact record the Medicare Program Integrity Manual requires.
The 30-Day Beneficiary Contact Window
CMS's refill rule, codified at 42 CFR 410.38(d)(4) and set out in the Medicare Program Integrity Manual, Chapter 5, section 5.2.6, effective January 1, 2024, requires the supplier to contact the beneficiary or a representative before dispensing a refill to the original order. The contact confirms the refilled item remains reasonable and necessary under the applicable local coverage determination and catches any change to the order before shipment. CMS wants the affirmative response obtained as close to the expected end of the current supply as possible, but sets an outer limit: the contact and the response must occur within 30 calendar days of that expected end date. Contact made well before that window opens fails the requirement regardless of how clearly the beneficiary expressed intent to continue the item.
Documenting the Refill Request
Documentation requirements go beyond the contact itself. The supplier's file must show the beneficiary's name, the date of contact, the specific item requested, and an affirmative response indicating the need for a refill, captured before the product ships. The affirmation of need is what the rule asks for, not an exact count of remaining supply. Suppliers may use any communication method, a phone call, a text message, or an email, so long as the record captures the beneficiary's name, the item, the date, and the affirmative response. For an item picked up in person at a retail location, a signed delivery slip or itemized sales receipt satisfies the requirement.
No Automatic or Pre-Determined Shipments
The rule forecloses a specific practice: shipping DMEPOS refills on a fixed schedule set in advance, without a fresh contact tied to each shipment. Even when a beneficiary signed a form authorizing standing refills at the start of service, the supplier must still contact the beneficiary before each individual shipment and obtain a new affirmative response for that shipment. A standing authorization does not substitute for contact tied to the specific refill. On audit, a MAC reviewing a batch of refill claims looks for a contact record attached to each shipment, not one blanket authorization covering the entire course of treatment.
Automatic shipment on a pre-determined schedule fails Medicare's refill rule even when the beneficiary authorized it in advance.
The 10-Day Delivery Window
Timing works from both ends of the shipment. Once the beneficiary's affirmative response is on file, the supplier still cannot deliver or ship the refill item more than 10 calendar days before the beneficiary's current supply runs out, regardless of the delivery method used. CMS directs DME MACs to allow claims for refills shipped within that 10-day window; a refill delivered earlier, even with a valid contact record on file, was delivered before the beneficiary exhausted the existing supply and risks denial on that basis alone.
Why Early Legal Counsel Is Critical
It is critical that DMEPOS suppliers promptly retain experienced healthcare defense counsel when a MAC flags refill documentation or opens a broader audit of recurring supply claims. Early legal intervention can confirm which contact and delivery records a MAC will accept, identify a documentation gap before the response deadline, and respond to a sample-based audit before extrapolation turns a handful of flagged refills into a demand covering the full claims universe reviewed. Delaying legal review until after a recoupment demand letter arrives can narrow the options available to contest it; how Medicare recovers that demand is covered separately in Recoupment in Medical Billing: What It Means and How Medicare Collects.
How Health Law Alliance Can Help
Health Law Alliance's attorneys have overseen 2,000+ audits and handled 5,000+ matters, with 25+ years of experience.
Health Law Alliance's DME audit defense attorneys review refill contact logs, delivery timestamps, and standing-order documentation before a MAC's sample expands into a broader demand. If your DMEPOS claims are under review for refill documentation, contact HLA's DME audit defense team for a free, confidential consultation.





