Skilled nursing facilities billing Medicare Part A face a 25% combined limit on group therapy and concurrent therapy minutes under the Patient Driven Payment Model (PDPM), applied separately to physical therapy, occupational therapy and speech-language pathology. CMS's Resident Assessment Instrument (RAI) Manual sets the rule: once group and concurrent minutes together exceed a quarter of a resident's total therapy minutes in a discipline over the entire Part A stay, CMS codes the assessment as non-compliant and generates a warning message on the facility's Final Validation Report. That ratio is what a Medicare audit defense review checks first once a facility's therapy billing comes under scrutiny, and the documentation behind it, not the warning itself, decides whether the stay survives.

The 25% Combined Limit

The limit traces to the fiscal year 2019 SNF PPS final rule that created PDPM (Federal Register document 2018-16570, published Aug. 8, 2018) and is administered today through the RAI Version 3.0 Manual, Chapter 3, Section O. The rule combines group and concurrent minutes into a single ceiling measured per discipline, not across all therapy combined. A resident can receive unlimited individual therapy, but group and concurrent minutes together cannot exceed 25% of the total minutes billed in any one discipline for that stay. CMS calculates the ratio from Minimum Data Set (MDS) item O0425 at discharge: total discipline minutes are split into individual, concurrent and group categories, concurrent and group minutes are added together, and that sum is divided by the total.

How CMS Defines Concurrent and Group Therapy

The RAI Manual defines concurrent therapy as the treatment of two residents who are not performing the same or similar activities at the same time, with both residents in the line of sight of the treating therapist or assistant. Group therapy is the treatment of two to six residents performing the same or similar activities, supervised by a therapist or assistant who is not supervising anyone else during that time. Minutes coded to the wrong category change the ratio CMS uses to measure compliance, and a single miscoded day can push a discipline over the 25% ceiling without a facility delivering one additional group minute.

A resident coded into group therapy who was actually treated one-on-one can turn a routine assessment into an overpayment finding.

How Auditors Count the Minutes

CMS's grouping software runs this calculation automatically once the PPS discharge assessment is submitted. Individual, concurrent and group minutes recorded in MDS item O0425 are totaled by discipline, and concurrent and group minutes are divided by that total. A result above 0.25 is coded as non-compliant and produces a warning on the Final Validation Report. CMS's manual ties that warning only to the assessment; a pattern of exceeded ratios can result in a facility being flagged for additional medical review, and a reviewed stay with weak documentation can turn into a recoupment demand built on an extrapolated sample rather than a single claim.

Documentation Failures That Draw Scrutiny

Audit findings in this area turn on whether the therapy record supports the mode of therapy billed, not on whether the 25% limit was technically exceeded. Recurring failures include progress notes describing one-on-one treatment on a day coded as group therapy, no documentation of which residents were treated together in a concurrent session, and therapy logs that never establish the line-of-sight requirement the RAI Manual's definition depends on. When a record cannot support the coded minutes, a reviewer can recharacterize the day's therapy against the skilled-services documentation standard in 42 CFR 409.44, which shifts the ratio and can support a broader extrapolated repayment demand. Facilities facing a PDPM therapy-minute audit should also understand how a related program integrity escalation works, covered in Medicare Payment Suspensions: Credible Allegations and the Path Back.

Why Early Legal Counsel Is Critical

It is critical that skilled nursing facilities promptly retain experienced healthcare defense counsel upon receiving a Medicare additional documentation request, program integrity referral, or any inquiry tied to therapy-minute discrepancies. Early legal intervention can protect the facility's rights, ensure the therapy record is assembled and presented correctly, avoid inadvertent admissions about coding practices, and preserve defenses before an extrapolated demand is calculated. Delaying legal representation can significantly affect the outcome of a matter and expose the facility to recoupment it could have avoided.

How Health Law Alliance Can Help

Health Law Alliance defends skilled nursing facilities through Medicare audits built on PDPM therapy-minute discrepancies, from the additional documentation request through appeal.

Health Law Alliance's attorneys have overseen 2,000+ audits and handled 5,000+ matters, with 25+ years of experience.

If your facility is facing a Medicare review of group or concurrent therapy minutes, contact Health Law Alliance for a free, confidential consultation through its skilled nursing facility audit defense practice.